Do you provide Scientific Literature Review?
How a scientific literature review for cosmetic claims is run
The work begins with a written question. A typical one names the ingredient or product, the concentration range, the type of formula, the application site and the benefit you want to describe. That question sets the search terms and decides which studies count as relevant.
Database search and screening
Reviewers search bibliographic databases such as PubMed, publisher platforms such as ScienceDirect and, where useful, technical literature and supplier data. The search strings, databases and dates are recorded so the search can be repeated. Titles and abstracts are screened against inclusion criteria, then the full texts of the remaining papers are read. Reviews that follow the PRISMA 2020 reporting guidance present this selection as a flow diagram from records found to studies included.
Appraising each study
For every included paper the reviewer records the material tested, its concentration and vehicle, the exposure time, the model (cell culture, reconstructed skin, ex vivo tissue or human volunteers), the comparator, the endpoints and the results. Study design and risk of bias are rated alongside. A double-blind, vehicle-controlled human study on a similar formula carries more weight for a finished-product claim than a cell assay at a higher dose.
What the review report contains
- Search strategy with databases, terms and dates
- Study selection record and inclusion criteria
- Evidence tables summarising each included study
- Appraisal of study quality and relevance to the claim
- Conclusions on support for each claim element, with gaps named
- Full bibliography
Some providers also offer periodic update searches, which flag new publications on the same question as they appear.
Putting a scientific literature review to work
A review is the fastest evidence you can commission, because it uses data that already exists. Product developers use it at concept stage to pick between candidate actives on the strength of their published human data. Claims teams use it to support ingredient-level statements such as a known mode of action. Before a clinical study, the review identifies the instruments and endpoints other researchers used for the same benefit, which feeds directly into cosmetic claim study design.
Briefing the reviewer
State the exact claim wording, the ingredient by INCI name, its concentration in your formula, the product type and the target consumer. Send supplier dossiers and any papers you already hold. Agree the depth of search in advance: a rapid scoping review answers a go or no-go question, while a full structured review with risk-of-bias assessment suits a claim that will appear on pack.
Judging a review provider
Ask for a sample evidence table and a search strategy from a past project. A capable reviewer reads full papers and reports the concentration and vehicle of every cited study. Check whether the team includes scientists who understand skin biology and cosmetic formulation, since they decide how closely a published model matches your product. The finished review slots into the claims substantiation dossier as one strand of the evidence.
More in Claims Evidence Planning
Claims evidence planning maps each proposed cosmetic claim to the published data and new studies needed to support it, before testing starts.

